Together, the three performed their 2021 hit, “Essence.” For Bieber, this was his second performance of 2024, having first broken his hiatus in February.

She and Bieber then performed his hit, “Sorry.” At the time, Bieber had taken a break from performing. “I haven’t been on stage in, like, two years,” he said in 2019.

Justin Bieber's fans have been critical of him in recent months. The tone of their comments have completely changed because ...